4.4 Yes-No Questions: The X-not-X Construction I

There are different ways to form yes-no questions. To form yes-no questions in the present tense, one way is to use the X-not-X construction.

In the X-not-X construction, where X represents the verb, we combine the positive form (X) and the negative form (not X) of the verb. To make the negative form, we simply add m4 (‘not’) before the verb.

Positive form
(X)
+Negative form
(not X)
=X-not-X

tai2
watch
+ 唔睇
m4 tai2
not watch
= 睇唔睇
tai2 m4 tai2

If the verb has more than one syllable, we keep only the first syllable and omit the other syllables in the positive form.

Positive form
(X)
+Negative form
(not X)
=X-not-X

zung1 ji3
like
+ 唔鐘意
m4 zung1 ji3
not like
= 鐘唔鐘意
zung1 m4 zung1 ji3

The actual meaning of a question using the X-not-X construction varies depending on the context. If the verb is a stative verb, such as 鍾意 zung1 ji3, the question usually asks whether a state is true or false, without assuming what the answer should be. It is like questions that begin with do you in English (e.g., Do you like hiking?).

  1. 你鍾唔鍾意行山嘅(嘅 + rising intonation)?
    nei5 zung1 m4 zung1 ji3 haang4 saan1 ge2 (ge3 + rising intonation)?
    Do you like hiking?

  2. 你鍾唔鍾意行山㗎(嘅 + 呀)?
    nei5 zung1 m4 zung1 ji3 haang4 saan1 gaa3 (ge3 + aa3)?
    Do you like hiking?

Notice the sentence particle 嘅 ge3 is added to the questions above. In this context, we are asking about someone’s likes and dislikes. This is similar to eliciting some facts.

To answer the question, we can give a short answer or a long answer. We give a short answer more often.

Long answerShort answer
Positive
answer
我鍾意行山呀。
ngo5 zung1 ji3 haang4 saan1 aa3.
Yes, I like hiking.
鍾意呀。
zung1 ji3 aa3.
Yes.
Negative
answer
我唔鍾意行山呀。
ngo5 m4 zung1 ji3 haang4 saan1 aa3.
No, I don’t like hiking.
唔鍾意呀。
m4 zung1 ji3 aa3.
No.

Cantonese doesn’t have words like yes and no in English that can be used for short answers. We form a short answer by keeping the verb and omitting the subject and the object in the long answer.

鍾意行山呀。
ngo5 zung1 ji3 haang4 saan1 aa3.
  ↓
鍾意呀。
zung1 ji3 aa3.

Notice the answers above end with the sentence particle 呀 aa3. We generally will use the sentence particle 呀 aa3 if we are simply answering “yes” or “no” (i.e. there isn’t anything special about the answer or anything we want to add after the answer). We may use other sentence particles in different situations, but we won’t examine them here.