31.5 The Preposition 同 tung4 II (‘for’)
In Grammar and Vocabulary 11.2, we learned that the preposition 同 tung4 means ‘with’.
The preposition 同 tung4 can also mean ‘for’ (as in I will refill the cups for you). When an action is done to help someone, we can use 同 tung4 to indicate who receives the help. We put a person after 同 tung4 to form a prepositional phrase.
We put the prepositional phrase before the verb we want to modify.
In Grammar and Vocabulary 24.1, we also learned to use the preposition 幫 bong1 (‘for’) to indicate who receives the help. 同 tung4 and 幫 bong1 are similar in this use, but 幫 bong1 usually conveys a clearer sense of help, as 幫 bong1 means ‘to help’ when used as a verb.
我同你哋加一加水呀吓。
ngo5 tung4 nei5 dei6 gaa1 jat1 gaa1 seoi2 aa3 haa2.
I will add water for you.
我幫你哋加一加水呀吓。
ngo5 bong1 nei5 dei6 gaa1 jat1 gaa1 seoi2 aa3 haa2.
I will add water for you.
The second sentence conveys a clearer sense of help than the first one.